Behind an unassuming “We Buy Gay Stuff” sign in San Francisco’s Castro district — complete with a striking leather daddy illustration — lies an unexpected treasure trove of queer history – AutoErotica, packed with artifacts from shuttered gay bars, vintage leather magazines, activist pins, and rare 8mm films; inside a bathroom, a young man lives three possible versions of the same encounter, each one exposing how fragile, violent, or tender desire can become when fate turns the handle; a newly out middle-aged lesbian panics before a third date and impulsively hires a sex worker to help her prepare; Sam and Adele are on a beach holiday in Portugal. When Sam locks eyes with Miguel, the attraction between them throws Sam, Adele, Miguel, and his friend Santiago into a new configuration; Sam and Dustin’s open marriage works… until a nosy friend asks if they ever have sex with just the two of them.